| Person | Type | Job | Role(s) | Episodes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 Cassandra Peterson | Cast | Actress | Elvira | 1 |
 Dan Didio | Cast | Actor | Self - Guest Judge | 1 |
 Doug Jones | Cast | Actor | Guest Judge | 1 |
 Elizabeth Mitchell | Cast | Actress | Guest Judge | 1 |
Jamie Kelman | Cast | Himself | 1 | |
 John Landis | Cast | Actor | Guest Judge | 1 |
 John Rhys-Davies | Cast | Actor | Self - Guest Judge | 1 |
 Jordu Schell | Cast | Actor | Himself | 1 |
 Lois Burwell | Cast | Actress | Guest Judge | 1 |
 McKenzie Westmore | Cast | Actress | Self - Host | 162 |
 Michael Westmore | Cast | Actor | Self - Mentor | 162 |
 Paul W. S. Anderson | Cast | Actor | Guest Judge | 1 |
 Rick Baker | Cast | Actor | Guest Judge | 2 |
 Suzanne Todd | Cast | Actress | Guest Judge | 1 |
 Todd Masters | Cast | Actor | Himself | 1 |
Ve Neill | Cast | Actress | Self - Judge | 162 |
 Cheyenne Jackson | Cast | Actor | Guest Judge | 1 |
 Jim Lee | Cast | Actor | Self - Guest Judge | 1 |
 John Wynn | Cast | Actor | Self | 1 |
 Marcus Nispel | Cast | Actor | Guest Judge | 1 |
Mike Mekash | Cast | Himself | 1 | |
 Neville Page | Cast | Actor | Self - Judge | 162 |
 Oren Peli | Cast | Actor | Self | 1 |
 Travis Wall | Cast | Actor | Guest Judge | 1 |
 Neil Druckmann | Cast | Actor | Guest Judge | 1 |
 Glenn Hetrick | Cast | Actor | Self - Judge | 162 |
 Eryn Krueger Mekash | Cast | Actress | Guest Judge | 1 |
 Nix Herrera | Cast | Self - Contestant | 10 | |
| Person | Type | Job | Role(s) | Episodes |
