| Person | Type | Job | Role(s) | Episodes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 Criss Angel | Crew | Creator | Creator | |
 Corbin Bleu | Cast | Actor | Self | 1 |
 Cynthia Bailey | Cast | Actress | Self | 1 |
 Debbie Gibson | Cast | Actress | Self | 1 |
 Donny Osmond | Cast | Actor | Self | 1 |
 Eddie Griffin | Cast | Actor | Self - Host | 10 |
 Flavor Flav | Cast | Actor | Self | 1 |
 Frankie Muniz | Cast | Actor | Self | 1 |
 Ginuwine | Cast | Actor | Self | 1 |
 Jeff Timmons | Cast | Actor | Self | 1 |
 Loni Love | Cast | Actress | Self - Judge | 10 |
 Matt Walsh | Cast | Actor | Self | 1 |
 Michael Ian Black | Cast | Actor | Self | 1 |
Criss Angel | Cast | Actor | Self - Judge | 10 |
 Frank Mir | Cast | Actor | Self | 1 |
 Johnny Weir | Cast | Actor | Self | 1 |
 Omarion | Cast | Actor | Self | 1 |
 Randy Couture | Cast | Actor | Self | 1 |
 Lolo Jones | Cast | Actress | Self | 1 |
 Miles Brown | Cast | Actor | Self | 1 |
 Brec Bassinger | Cast | Actress | Self | 1 |
 Tara Lipinski | Cast | Actress | Self | 1 |
 Lance Burton | Cast | Actor | Self - Judge | 10 |
 Vernon Davis | Cast | Actor | Self | 1 |
 Maksim Chmerkovskiy | Cast | Actor | Self | 1 |
| Person | Type | Job | Role(s) | Episodes |
